The most important part of this set is a footnote in problem 6. It is where orbital angular momentum is shown to have no half-integer values, and the book does not flag it.
Nine problems, and they divide cleanly. 1β2 are counting and correspondence: how many states, and how large must get before quantization stops showing. 3β4 are the numbers β Zeeman splittings and the rigid rotor, and problem 4 lands on a result about hydrogen molecules that is worth carrying away. 5β8 build the machinery Β§8.3 used without proving: that , that is an integer, and which functions solve the angular equation. 9 goes back to Β§6.5βs three-dimensional oscillator and sorts its degenerate levels by angular momentum.
Counting and correspondence
A particle has orbital angular momentum and spin .
(a) How many distinct states are there with different values for the components of the orbital and spin angular momenta? (b) What are the possible values of ? (c) How many distinct states are there with different values for the magnitude and component of the total angular momentum?
(The book adds a note: the number of distinct states equals the number of distinct states.)
β Worked solution
(a) takes values and takes , independently:
(b) Eq. (8.6) runs from down to in steps of 1:
(c) Each carries values of :
The counts agree, and the note is telling you this is not a coincidence. The labels and describe the same 21 states β coupling is a change of basis, and a change of basis cannot alter a dimension. That is also why Eq. (8.6) stops at : sort the uncoupled states by into a staircase and peel multiplets off the top, and the columns run out exactly there.
The staircase is why Eq. (8.6) stops where it does. Peel the widest multiplet off the top of the stack, then the next, and the columns run out exactly when j reaches |l β s|. Try l = 3, s = 1 β problem 1's case: 21 states either way.
A classical electron moves in a circle with a given radius and speed. (a) What value of gives a quantized angular momentum close to this classical one? (b) How many discrete values are possible for its component? (c) How closely spaced are these values, as a fraction of the magnitude?
π‘ Phillips' own hint
The classical angular momentum J s is approximately equal to if .
β Worked solution
(a) Setting J s gives , so
(b) discrete values of .
(c) Adjacent values differ by , against a magnitude :
And that is the answer the problem is really after. A 1.16% step is already hard to resolve; for a spinning object of everyday size is around and the steps are of the total. The quantization never switches off β there are always exactly values β it just becomes unmeasurably fine. Β§8.1βs widget makes the same point with the cone angle, which at is already down to .
Putting numbers on the magnetism
The ground state of hydrogen has zero orbital angular momentum, with magnetic moments given by Eqs. (8.8) and (8.12). The atom is placed in a field of 0.5 T.
(a) Explain why, ignoring the protonβs moment, the ground state splits into two levels, and find the spacing in eV. (b) Explain why each of those levels is itself split in two when the protonβs moment is included, and find that spacing.
π‘ Phillips' own hint
(a) The splitting arises from the interaction of the electron magnetic moment with the field. By Eq. (8.16) it is eV.
(b) Additional splitting equal to eV arises from the proton magnetic moment.
β Worked solution
(a) With the only angular momentum is the electronβs spin, , so β two states. By Eq. (8.8) their magnetic energies are , i.e. , so the gap is
(b) The proton is also spin-Β½, so it has its own two orientations, and Eq. (8.12) gives its moment as . Each electron level therefore splits again, by
Four levels in total, in two widely separated pairs β the electron splitting is 658 times the proton splitting, because and the protonβs 2.79 recovers only part of that.
Two masses are attached to the ends of a massless rod of length , free to rotate in three dimensions about the centre of mass.
(a) Write down the classical rotational kinetic energy, and show the quantum levels are
(b) What is the degeneracy of the -th level? (c) The Hβ molecule is two protons 0.075 nm apart. Find the energy needed to excite the first excited rotational state.
π‘ Phillips' own hint
(a) The classical rotational energy is where is the moment of inertia about the centre of mass. Here , and the eigenvalues of are .
(b) For every , can have values, so there are independent eigenfunctions with energy .
(c) eV. Note that the rotational states of the hydrogen molecule are excited at room temperature, because eV.
β Worked solution
(a) Each mass sits at distance from the centre, so
Classically . This system has no potential energy at all β nothing but rotation β so the Hamiltonian is and its eigenvalues follow immediately from Eq. (8.23):
(b) , one for each β the field-free degeneracy that Β§8.2βs magnetic field lifts.
(c) With and nm,
Now compare with at room temperature, which is eV. The rotational excitation costs less than the thermal energy available, so Hβ molecules in a room are rotating β the states are thermally populated.
The machinery Β§8.3 used on credit
(a) Using , , and the chain rule, show that
(b) Verify that is an eigenfunction of with eigenvalue . (c) Explain why it is not unreasonable to assume , and show this implies is an integer. (d) Show is 1 if and 0 otherwise. (e) Show that if then .
π‘ Phillips' own hint
(a) Show that .
(b) A point with coordinates also has coordinates .
β Worked solution
(a) By the chain rule, . From the coordinate relations, , , and . Substituting,
which is exactly the bracket in .
(b) .
(c) and are the same point in space, so a wave function that assigns two different values to them would not be a function of position. Requiring gives , and hence
(d) . For the integrand is 1 and the result is 1; otherwise the exponential completes a whole number of cycles and integrates to zero.
(e) Multiply the expansion by and integrate. By (d) every term vanishes except the one with matching index, which returns .
A wave function has azimuthal dependence . What are the possible outcomes of a measurement of , and their probabilities?
π‘ Phillips' own hint
Use and , and show that
Comparison with Eq. (8.27) shows a measurement of can yield four possible values , , and with equal probabilities of 1/4.
β Worked solution
Multiplying the two exponential forms:
Four terms, all of the same magnitude. Comparing with Eq. (8.27), the outcomes are , each with probability .
Note which values are absent: and never occur. A product of trigonometric functions does not spread over every harmonic β it picks out a specific few, exactly as multiplying two signals in DSP produces sum and difference frequencies and nothing else.
A wave function has azimuthal dependence . What are the possible outcomes of a measurement of , and their probabilities?
β Worked solution
Use the same trick:
So with amplitudes in the ratio . Squaring gives , and normalizing by their sum :
Compare with problem 6. There, four equal amplitudes gave four equal probabilities. Here the amplitudes are unequal, and squaring exaggerates the imbalance: a 2:1 amplitude ratio becomes 4:1 in probability. Confirmed numerically above.
Note also that is real and even, so its decomposition is symmetric in β the state has even though it is not an eigenstate.
In spherical polars,
Show that the simultaneous eigenfunctions of and have the form , where obeys
Finite solutions exist on only for and . Find by substitution the and for which , and are solutions.
β Worked solution
Separation. acts only on , so its eigenfunctions fix the dependence as (problem 5). Substituting into , the term returns , the exponential cancels throughout, and the stated ODE remains.
The three substitutions.
: both derivatives vanish, leaving for all . The -dependent term must vanish on its own, so , and then gives . .
: and , so the equation becomes . Again , and gives .
: substituting and multiplying through by leaves . Both pieces must vanish separately, giving and : .
These are exactly Table 8.1βs entries, recovered from the differential equation rather than quoted.
Back to the oscillator
Reconsider Β§6.5βs three-dimensional harmonic oscillator. Using Table 8.1, linear combinations of its degenerate eigenfunctions can be made into simultaneous eigenfunctions of energy, and .
(a) Verify that the eigenfunction with energy has , . (b) Construct eigenfunctions with energy and , . (c) Construct eigenfunctions with energy and , , and one with , .
π‘ Phillips' own hint
(a) The eigenfunction with energy has and because it is spherically symmetric.
(b) Form linear combinations of eigenfunctions with energy which are proportional to , and .
β Worked solution
The 3-D oscillatorβs level has energy and degeneracy , with eigenfunctions being polynomials of degree in times the Gaussian .
(a) : one state, the bare Gaussian. It depends only on , so it is spherically symmetric β and Β§8.3a proved . Hence , .
(b) : three states, spanned by , , times the Gaussian. Table 8.1 says the combinations with definite are
all with , since each is times a .
(c) : six states, spanned by the quadratics times the Gaussian. Five combinations match β for instance gives , gives , and gives . That accounts for five.
The sixth is itself, which is spherically symmetric and therefore has , .
So : this level carries two different values of at the same energy.
Between the extremes: 1 nodal circle, and the density is pulled partway toward the equator. Note there is no dependence on Ο, whatever l and m β because |eimΟ|Β² = 1. A definite Lz means the wave function is completely smeared around the z axis.
Check yourself
0 / 6 answered
1.Problem 5(c) requires . Why is that the deepest part of this problem set?
Problem 6 gives four equal probabilities of ΒΌ; problem 7 gives β , β , β .
2.Why does produce such lopsided probabilities when does not?
3.Problem 4(c) gives eV for Hβ, against eV at room temperature. What does the comparison explain?
4.Problem 8 finds that solves the angular equation for both and . Why can the equation not tell them apart?
5.Problem 9(c) finds six degenerate states at , splitting as (five states) plus (one). Why can they not all belong to a single ?
6.Problem 2's printed radius and speed give J s, while its hint says J s with . Why is this not a harmless typo?